General Information
Intimacy Level (Some sort of Friends)
Started Friendship My Babysitter's a Vampire (film)
Friendship Status Friends/Kissed
Bennica (Benny and Erica) is the friendship/romantic pairing of Benny and Erica. Erica doesn't appear to have feelings for Benny due to him being unpopular, though she prefers him to his best friend, Ethan Morgan. Due to a love potion, she kisses him and despite the attention from other girls he stays with her. By season two, they are closer friends and Erica no longer treats Benny as she did in season one, as if he doesn't exist.
 He considers her a friend, but as always, he still has a crush on her. In Village of the Darned they have quite a few moments, and it's shown that Erica might have a possible crush on Benny, but it's unknown.This relationship is very likely

This ship currently rivals. Benthan, Sarica, GoricaRorica, Jerica, Ronny, Ethica, Erik, and Besse.

Additional Pairing Names.

  •  Berica (Benny/Erica)
  • Erenny (Erica/Benny)
  • Erennica (Erica/Benny) (with ica at the end)
  • Bennica (Benny/Erica)

Bennica Moments

My Babysitter's a Vampire: The Movie

  • Benny is revealed to have a crush on Erica.
  • Benny calls her the "Princess Leia" to his "Han Solo."
  • Benny said it was too good to be real that Erica was his nanny
  • Benny went to ask erica if she was Morgan's nanny
  • When they are out of school Benny looks at Erica very much in love and tells Ethan not to miss home
  • Just before Sarah leaves after taking care of the pizza guy, Benny says, "Say hi to Erica for me."
  • Benny seems to have more interest in Erica than in Sarah and the other girls
  • When they are in the dining room of the school and Erica and Sarah they get up, erica is observed looking at Benny

  • Benny looks a little disappointed when Rory reloads on Erica

Season 1

Three Cheers for Evil

  • Benny told Ethan that he had to help the cheerleaders and Erica was one the cheerleaders.
  • Benny wanted to enter the girls' dressing room (where Erica was)
  • Benny smiled at Erica when the cheerleaders pass through the lunch room.

Blood Drive

  • Benny kept looking over at Erica when she was putting needles in her nurse coat pocket.
  • Benny was the most surprised when he saw Erica kissing Rory

Benny was the only one who knew that Erica had taken the blood from the truck when she said that Erica would not be hungry in a long time (which means they were talking, or Benny was watching Erica)

Guys and Dolls

  • When Erica got up she was dancing with Sarah when Benny came and they complimented each other on their dances.

Double Negative

  • Benny and Erica both have lists of people they want to hurt.
  • Benny and Erica smile at each other various times in that scene.

Smells Like Trouble

  • After smelling the love potion, Erica goes to Benny instead of Ethan, which shows she might like him better or be more attracted to his pheromones.
  • Erica kisses Benny

  • Benny enjoys their kiss.
  • Even though many girls are after him, Benny sticks with Erica, showing he prefers her.
  • When the girls were under the love potion and wanted to hurt Benny, Erica said she was going to hurt him first showing she prefers him.
  • Under the potion Erica falls for Benny.
  • Erica compliments Benny's shirt.
  • When Erica and Sarah leaves the hallway Erica waves to Benny in a flirty way.

erica and benny

Die Pod

  • Benny says he carves in the tree the names of the girls he's in love with, one of them being Erica's.
  • Benny gets jealous when Rory says that he and Erica like a single tear, and Benny says that if they like the same band it will not make much difference. From there Benny is a little angry with Rory
  • At the time of mentioning the names that stalk the girls you love. When Erica mentions her smile grows bigger

Blue Moon

  • After Erica wants David to feed on Benny, Benny says he thought they were friends.
  • After Erica touches Ethan, thinking he's David, she rubs her hands on Benny to get rid of "Ethan germs." This shows she doesn't think Benny has germs and she prefers him to Ethan, at least.
  • Benny seems a little jealous that Erica likes David.


  • Benny asks Erica if she's going to the dance.
  • Benny asks Erica what Sarah's doing.
  • Erica replies "saving him" quite politely, as opposed to her snarky attitude.

Season 2

Welcome Back Dusker

  • When Benny and Ethan are together and Erica and Sarah show up, Erica and Benny start talking in a friendly way.
  • After Sarah dumps the assistant principal in the trash, Erica says she'll handle it and runs away to get Benny. This could possibly mean that she trusts that Benny knows how to handle the situation with his magic.
  • Once she gets Benny, she stays arm in arm with him.
  • Erica asks him to do the memory spell, meaning she knows he had perfected it. which means they talked and spent time together during the period of time sarah wasn't there.

Say You'll Be Maztak

  • Erica becomes jealous when Benny (and Ethan) pay more attention to Lucia than to her
  • Benny fights Erica while Sarah fights Rory
  • Before they fight, Benny tells Erica (and Sarah) that she looks hot. This shows even under Lucia's love spell he still thinks Erica is attractive.

Fanged and Furious

  • When Benny puts a spell on Erica and himself (and Rory), they wake up right next to each other.
  • When Erica leaves the car Benny leaves too.


  • When Benny leaves excited about going to see some "hotties" Erica looks jealous.
  • When they were making the potion, Erica said that their proportions were off and Rory asked how she knew that. Benny said that before she was a smoking hot vampire she was a mega nerd. This shows that even before she was a vampire Benny noticed Erica showing he had an interest in her and he called her smoking hot.
  • When Ethan asked who should be bait Erica pointed to Rory who moved her hand so she was pointing at Benny, but she quickly moved it back implying that she didn't want Benny to be the bait and get hurt.
  • When the boys got rid of the alligator, Erica smiled at Benny (and Ethan) when they high-fived each other.
  • When the boys were walking down the hallway, Erica is looking at Benny.
  • Even though Benny got scared when Erica hissed at him, he looked as if he knew she wouldn't hurt him.
  • Benny gets jealous when Erica says to crave a blonde, Benny answers very annoying "do not tell me" and changes his attitude to angry


  • In the beginning you see both Benny and Erica are interested in signing up for the play.
  • When they both go to sign up Benny and Erica touch hands.

  • Benny gives her a shy smile and says, "Age before beauty" and Erica lightly smiles.

  • Erica and Benny stared at each other when they both went to sign up for the Rainbow play.

  • When Erica (being possesed by Olivia) knocks down some of his equipment, Benny takes the blame for her even though he didn't know what was going on with her.

  • Benny called Erica "bitey".

  • Benny smiled at Erica when they were by the theater seats.
  • At one point in the end, when Ethan was painting the mirror black, they are seen standing next to each other.

Village of the Darned

  • Erica liked the taste of Benny's blood, and could not stop thinking about it (and him).
  • Benny helped Erica up when she collapsed.
  • Erica was thinking about Benny when he left with Rory and Ethan.
  • Benny said "here comes the hot-ness express" when Erica and Sarah walk toward them.
  • Benny helped Erica find a blood source.
  • Benny looked back at Erica when he was walking away.
  • Benny chuckled at Erica's joke to Ethan. ("What are you afraid that they're going to color outside the lines?")
  • As they (Ethan, Sarah, Benny, Erica, and Rory) formulate a plan, they are seen standing next to each other.
  • Benny makes a comment about Erica's tail, and she smacks him with it, him responding with, "Oh, it's like sand paper!"
    Benny y erica

    bennica :) forever

Fan Fictions

All videos belong to their rightful owners.

Bennica/Video Gallery

My Babysitter's a Vampire~Use Your Love ♥Erica Benny♥

My Babysitter's a Vampire~Use Your Love ♥Erica Benny♥


Kiss the Lady Already! Benny♥Erica

Kiss the Lady Already! Benny♥Erica